Ship To Me!
PLEASE NOTE: DURING THE BUSY SUMMER SEASON, WE ARE NOT ABLE TO SHIP OUR KEY LIME PIES. SHIPPING WILL RESUME IN SEPTEMBER. THANK YOU FOR YOUR UNDERSTANDING!
Order handmade Key Lime Pies shipped frozen nationwide for guaranteed fresh delivery. Our small-batch pies are crafted using real, high-quality ingredients. Choose from whole pies, mini pie 4-packs, gluten-free mini 4-packs, and chocolate-dipped slices — the best key lime pie delivery for gifts, holidays, or a taste of the beach at home.
Overnight (1-day) shipping must be selected at checkout to complete your order. Orders received by 8:00 AM EST will be available to ship same day.
Product pricing below includes:
- One-day UPS ground shipping to DE, NJ, MD, and DC (additional shipping fees will be added for deliveries to all other states for Next Day Air shipping costs)
- Dry ice to keep your pie frozen in transit
- Eco-friendly insulated packaging
-
Original price $69.00 - Original price $69.00Original price$69.00$69.00 - $69.00Current price $69.00Whole Key Lime Pie (9") (SHIP TO ME!)
Coastal Key Lime PieThe Ultimate Key Lime Pie – Handmade Perfection in Every Bite! Indulge in the perfect harmony of tangy and sweet with our handmade-from-scratch Key...
View full detailsOriginal price $69.00 - Original price $69.00Original price$69.00$69.00 - $69.00Current price $69.00 -
Original price $72.00 - Original price $72.00Original price$72.00$72.00 - $72.00Current price $72.00Chocolate Dipped Key Lime Pie (4 Pops) (SHIP TO ME!)
Coastal Key Lime PieChocolate-Dipped Key Lime Pie Pop – A Tropical Indulgence with a Chocolatey Twist! Experience the ultimate dessert fusion with our handmade Chocola...
View full detailsOriginal price $72.00 - Original price $72.00Original price$72.00$72.00 - $72.00Current price $72.00 -
Original price $76.00 - Original price $76.00Original price$76.00$76.00 - $76.00Current price $76.00Mini Key Lime Pie (5") (4 Pies) (SHIP TO ME!)
Coastal Key Lime PieMini Key Lime Pie 4-Pack – A Bite-Sized Vacation in Every Bite! Escape to paradise with our handmade Mini Key Lime Pie 4-Pack—the perfect way to in...
View full detailsOriginal price $76.00 - Original price $76.00Original price$76.00$76.00 - $76.00Current price $76.00 -
Original price $88.00 - Original price $88.00Original price$88.00$88.00 - $88.00Current price $88.00GLUTEN FREE Mini Key Lime Pie (4 Mini Pies) (SHIP TO ME!)
Coastal Key Lime PieGluten-Free Mini Key Lime Pie 4-Pack – Indulgence Without Limits! Satisfy your cravings with our handmade, gluten-free Mini Key Lime Pie—crafted fo...
View full detailsOriginal price $88.00 - Original price $88.00Original price$88.00$88.00 - $88.00Current price $88.00 -
Original price $82.00 - Original price $82.00Original price$82.00$82.00 - $82.00Current price $82.00Mini Key Lime Pie (5") Variety Pack (Gluten & Gluten Free) (4 Pies) (SHIP TO ME!)
Coastal Key Lime PieVariety is the spice of life! Satisfy your gluten loving AND gluten free key lime pie fans with this 4-pack of mini key lime pies. Package includ...
View full detailsOriginal price $82.00 - Original price $82.00Original price$82.00$82.00 - $82.00Current price $82.00 -
Original price $10.00 - Original price $100.00Original price$10.00 - $100.00$10.00 - $100.00Current price $10.00Coastal Key Lime Pie Digital Gift Card
Coastal Key Lime PieGive the gift of paradise with a Coastal Key Lime Pie Gift Card! Perfect for birthdays, holidays, thank-yous, or “just because,” our digital gift c...
View full detailsOriginal price $10.00 - Original price $100.00Original price$10.00 - $100.00$10.00 - $100.00Current price $10.00 -
Original price $10.00 - Original price $100.00Original price$10.00 - $100.00$10.00 - $100.00Current price $10.00
Coastal Key Lime Pie PHYSICAL Gift Card
Coastal Key Lime PieGive the gift of paradise with a Coastal Key Lime Pie Gift Card! Perfect for birthdays, holidays, thank-yous, or “just because,” our digital gift c...
View full detailsOriginal price $10.00 - Original price $100.00Original price$10.00 - $100.00$10.00 - $100.00Current price $10.00
