Handmade in small batches. Packed with dry ice and delivered frozen so every bite tastes like you’re on vacation.
✔ Ships Overnight Nationwide
✔ Guaranteed Frozen Arrival
✔ Family-Owned & Operated
✔ Handmade In Small Batches
Trusted by families, food lovers, and key lime pie fans across the country!
Bright, creamy, perfectly tart — our signature Key Lime Pie is handmade with real key lime juice and a buttery, coconutty, graham cracker crust.
Select your delivery date at checkout. Ships overnight Monday through Thursday, for Tuesday through Friday delivery. Enter a gift note or special delivery instructions at checkout.
CONTAINS: Milk, Egg, Wheat, Coconut, Soy
Four-pack of 5" mini pies, handmade in small batches and shipped frozen. Perfect for gifts, parties, or when you want “just a little slice of sunshine.” Each mini pie serves 1-2. Pack includes 4 mini pies.
Select your delivery date at checkout. Ships overnight Monday through Thursday, for Tuesday through Friday delivery. Enter a gift note or special delivery instructions at checkout.
CONTAINS: Milk, Egg, Wheat, Coconut, Soy
Our decadent coastal delight: a frozen Key Lime Pie slice dipped in smooth Ghirardelli dark chocolate, served on a stick. Refreshing, fun, and totally unforgettable.
Select your delivery date at checkout. Ships overnight Monday through Thursday, for Tuesday through Friday delivery. Enter a gift note or special delivery instructions at checkout.
CONTAINS: Milk, Egg, Wheat, Coconut, Soy
The same perfectly balanced filling paired with our gluten-free graham crust. Certified delicious and loved by gluten-free customers nationwide. Pack contains four 5" mini gluten free pies. Each mini pie serves 1-2.
Select your delivery date at checkout. Ships overnight Monday through Thursday, for Tuesday through Friday delivery. Enter a gift note or special delivery instructions at checkout.
CONTAINS: Milk, Egg, Coconut
"Absolutely the BEST key lime pie out there!"
Greg Meleney
"As Key Lime Pies go, Coastal is AUTHENTICALLY the BEST ever! Flavorful, Creamy, Fresh. And that Crust! ...or shall I say "buttery, cookie crust," an Outstanding compliment to that Wonderful Filling!"
Susan Slw
"Recently had Coastal Key Lime Pie for the first time and both my wife and I LOVED them! Perfectly balanced key lime pie! Not too sweet, not too tart... just perfect!"
Scott Shelley
Your key lime pie stays frozen for 24 hours during overnight transit, ensuring perfect texture and flavor.
Thermal liners protect your key lime pie from temperature swings along the way.
If your order doesn’t arrive frozen, we’ll make it right — guaranteed.
Stock up for celebrations, last-minute desserts, or gifting.
We’re Jessica and Lee — the husband-and-wife team behind Coastal Key Lime Pie. What started in our family kitchen has grown into a beloved coastal bakery known for small-batch Key Lime Pies made with real key lime juice, quality ingredients, and a whole lot of heart.
Every pie is crafted by hand, frozen with care, and shipped from our little corner of Delaware to homes across the country. We’re honored to share a taste of our coastal sunshine with you!
Yes! We ship overnight to all 50 states using insulated packaging and dry ice.
Absolutely. Every order is packed to stay frozen for 24 hours, with a frozen arrival guarantee.
Place the pie in the refrigerator for 3–4 hours, or on the countertop for 30-45 minutes. You can also cut and thaw individual slices for a quicker treat. We recommend keeping chocolate dipped slices frozen - enjoy straight from the freezer!
Up to 6 months in the freezer, or 6 days in the fridge once thawed. We recommend keeping chocolate dipped slices frozen - enjoy straight from the freezer!
Yes — our Gluten-Free Mini Key Lime Pie 4-Pack is one of our most popular products.
Perfect for birthdays, Mother’s Day, Father's Day, holidays, housewarmings, corporate gifts, and more! (No pricing is included in the box.) You can also add a custom note at checkout, to ensure your recipient knows who the pie is coming from.
